Advances in Computational Studies of the Liquid-Liquid Transition in Water and Water-Like Models

Jeremy C. Palmer, Peter H. Poole, Francesco Sciortino, Pablo Gaston Debenedetti

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

32 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

There has been uninterrupted interest in supercooled water ever since the pioneering experiments of Speedy and Angell revealed sharp increases in this substance's response functions upon supercooling. One intriguing hypothesis that was formulated to explain this behavior involves the existence of a metastable liquid-liquid transition (LLT) at deeply supercooled conditions. The preponderance of experimental evidence is consistent with this hypothesis, although no definitive proof exists to date. Computational studies have played an important role in this area, because ice nucleation can in principle be controlled in silico. It has been claimed, controversially, that the LLT is a misinterpreted liquid-solid transition in all models of water. Recent studies disprove this viewpoint by providing unambiguous counter-examples of distinct liquid-liquid and liquid-crystal transitions in tetrahedral models. In one, state-of-the-art sampling methods were used to compute the free energy surface of a molecular model of water and revealed the existence of two liquid phases in metastable equilibrium with each other and a stable crystal phase, at the same, deeply supercooled thermodynamic conditions. Further studies showed that, by tuning the potential parameters of a model tetrahedral system, it is possible to make the LLT evolve continuously from metastability to being thermodynamically stable with respect to crystallization. Most recently, it has been shown that the simulation code used to challenge the hypothesis of an LLT contains conceptual errors that invalidate the results on which the challenge was based, definitively resolving the controversy. The debate has vastly expanded the range of fundamental questions being pursued about phase transitions in metastable systems and ushered the use of increasingly sophisticated computational methods to explore the possible existence of LLTs in model systems.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)9129-9151
Number of pages23
JournalChemical Reviews
Volume118
Issue number18
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 26 2018

Fingerprint

Water
Liquids
Liquid Crystals
Supercooling
Ice
Computational methods
Crystallization
Free energy
Nucleation
Tuning
Phase transitions
Thermodynamics
Sampling
Crystals
Experiments

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Chemistry(all)

Cite this

Palmer, Jeremy C. ; Poole, Peter H. ; Sciortino, Francesco ; Debenedetti, Pablo Gaston. / Advances in Computational Studies of the Liquid-Liquid Transition in Water and Water-Like Models. In: Chemical Reviews. 2018 ; Vol. 118, No. 18. pp. 9129-9151.
@article{04fc6c850cb14262a1d35cad86c57ee6,
title = "Advances in Computational Studies of the Liquid-Liquid Transition in Water and Water-Like Models",
abstract = "There has been uninterrupted interest in supercooled water ever since the pioneering experiments of Speedy and Angell revealed sharp increases in this substance's response functions upon supercooling. One intriguing hypothesis that was formulated to explain this behavior involves the existence of a metastable liquid-liquid transition (LLT) at deeply supercooled conditions. The preponderance of experimental evidence is consistent with this hypothesis, although no definitive proof exists to date. Computational studies have played an important role in this area, because ice nucleation can in principle be controlled in silico. It has been claimed, controversially, that the LLT is a misinterpreted liquid-solid transition in all models of water. Recent studies disprove this viewpoint by providing unambiguous counter-examples of distinct liquid-liquid and liquid-crystal transitions in tetrahedral models. In one, state-of-the-art sampling methods were used to compute the free energy surface of a molecular model of water and revealed the existence of two liquid phases in metastable equilibrium with each other and a stable crystal phase, at the same, deeply supercooled thermodynamic conditions. Further studies showed that, by tuning the potential parameters of a model tetrahedral system, it is possible to make the LLT evolve continuously from metastability to being thermodynamically stable with respect to crystallization. Most recently, it has been shown that the simulation code used to challenge the hypothesis of an LLT contains conceptual errors that invalidate the results on which the challenge was based, definitively resolving the controversy. The debate has vastly expanded the range of fundamental questions being pursued about phase transitions in metastable systems and ushered the use of increasingly sophisticated computational methods to explore the possible existence of LLTs in model systems.",
author = "Palmer, {Jeremy C.} and Poole, {Peter H.} and Francesco Sciortino and Debenedetti, {Pablo Gaston}",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "26",
doi = "https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.8b00228",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "118",
pages = "9129--9151",
journal = "Chemical Reviews",
issn = "0009-2665",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "18",

}

Advances in Computational Studies of the Liquid-Liquid Transition in Water and Water-Like Models. / Palmer, Jeremy C.; Poole, Peter H.; Sciortino, Francesco; Debenedetti, Pablo Gaston.

In: Chemical Reviews, Vol. 118, No. 18, 26.09.2018, p. 9129-9151.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

TY - JOUR

T1 - Advances in Computational Studies of the Liquid-Liquid Transition in Water and Water-Like Models

AU - Palmer, Jeremy C.

AU - Poole, Peter H.

AU - Sciortino, Francesco

AU - Debenedetti, Pablo Gaston

PY - 2018/9/26

Y1 - 2018/9/26

N2 - There has been uninterrupted interest in supercooled water ever since the pioneering experiments of Speedy and Angell revealed sharp increases in this substance's response functions upon supercooling. One intriguing hypothesis that was formulated to explain this behavior involves the existence of a metastable liquid-liquid transition (LLT) at deeply supercooled conditions. The preponderance of experimental evidence is consistent with this hypothesis, although no definitive proof exists to date. Computational studies have played an important role in this area, because ice nucleation can in principle be controlled in silico. It has been claimed, controversially, that the LLT is a misinterpreted liquid-solid transition in all models of water. Recent studies disprove this viewpoint by providing unambiguous counter-examples of distinct liquid-liquid and liquid-crystal transitions in tetrahedral models. In one, state-of-the-art sampling methods were used to compute the free energy surface of a molecular model of water and revealed the existence of two liquid phases in metastable equilibrium with each other and a stable crystal phase, at the same, deeply supercooled thermodynamic conditions. Further studies showed that, by tuning the potential parameters of a model tetrahedral system, it is possible to make the LLT evolve continuously from metastability to being thermodynamically stable with respect to crystallization. Most recently, it has been shown that the simulation code used to challenge the hypothesis of an LLT contains conceptual errors that invalidate the results on which the challenge was based, definitively resolving the controversy. The debate has vastly expanded the range of fundamental questions being pursued about phase transitions in metastable systems and ushered the use of increasingly sophisticated computational methods to explore the possible existence of LLTs in model systems.

AB - There has been uninterrupted interest in supercooled water ever since the pioneering experiments of Speedy and Angell revealed sharp increases in this substance's response functions upon supercooling. One intriguing hypothesis that was formulated to explain this behavior involves the existence of a metastable liquid-liquid transition (LLT) at deeply supercooled conditions. The preponderance of experimental evidence is consistent with this hypothesis, although no definitive proof exists to date. Computational studies have played an important role in this area, because ice nucleation can in principle be controlled in silico. It has been claimed, controversially, that the LLT is a misinterpreted liquid-solid transition in all models of water. Recent studies disprove this viewpoint by providing unambiguous counter-examples of distinct liquid-liquid and liquid-crystal transitions in tetrahedral models. In one, state-of-the-art sampling methods were used to compute the free energy surface of a molecular model of water and revealed the existence of two liquid phases in metastable equilibrium with each other and a stable crystal phase, at the same, deeply supercooled thermodynamic conditions. Further studies showed that, by tuning the potential parameters of a model tetrahedral system, it is possible to make the LLT evolve continuously from metastability to being thermodynamically stable with respect to crystallization. Most recently, it has been shown that the simulation code used to challenge the hypothesis of an LLT contains conceptual errors that invalidate the results on which the challenge was based, definitively resolving the controversy. The debate has vastly expanded the range of fundamental questions being pursued about phase transitions in metastable systems and ushered the use of increasingly sophisticated computational methods to explore the possible existence of LLTs in model systems.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85052870406&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85052870406&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.8b00228

DO - https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.8b00228

M3 - Review article

C2 - 30152693

VL - 118

SP - 9129

EP - 9151

JO - Chemical Reviews

JF - Chemical Reviews

SN - 0009-2665

IS - 18

ER -