Strong gravitational lensing statistics as a test of cosmogonic scenarios

Renyue Cen, J. Richard Gott, Jeremiah P. Ostriker, Edwin Lewis Turner

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

44 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Gravitational lensing statistics can provide a direct and powerful test of cosmic structure formation theories. Since lensing tests, directly, the magnitude of the nonlinear mass density fluctuations on lines of sight to distant objects, no issues of "bias" (of mass fluctuations with respect to galaxy density fluctuations) exist here, although lensing observations provide their own ambiguities of interpretation. We develop numerical techniques for generating model density distributions with the very large spatial dynamic range required by lensing considerations and for identifying regions of the simulations capable of multiple image lensing in a conservative and computationally efficient way that should be accurate for splittings significantly larger than 3″. Applying these techniques to existing standard Cold dark matter (CDM) (Ω = 1) and Primeval Baryon Isocurvature (PBI) (Ω = 0.2) simulations (normalized to the COBE amplitude), we find that the CDM model predicts large splitting (>8″) lensing events roughly an order-of-magnitude more frequently than the PBI model. Under the reasonable but idealized assumption that lensing structures can be modeled as singular isothermal spheres (SIS), the predictions can be directly compared to observations of lensing events in quasar samples. Several large splitting (Δθ > 8″) cases are predicted in the standard CDM model (the exact number being dependent on the treatment of amplification bias), whereas none is observed. In a formal sense, the comparison excludes the CDM model at high confidence (essentially for the same reason that CDM predicts excessive small-scale cosmic velocity dispersions.) A very rough assessment of low-density but flat CDM model (Ω = 0.3, Λ/3H2 0 = 0.7) indicates a far lower and probably acceptable level of lensing. The PBI model is consistent with, but not strongly tested by, the available lensing data, and other open models would presumably do as well as PBI. These preliminary conclusions and the assumptions on which they are based can be tested and the analysis can be applied to other cosmogonic models by straightforward extension of the work presented here.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1-11
Number of pages11
JournalAstrophysical Journal
Volume423
Issue number1
StatePublished - Mar 1 1994

Fingerprint

statistics
dark matter
baryons
test
Cosmic Background Explorer satellite
ambiguity
quasars
line of sight
dynamic range
simulation
density distribution
cold
confidence
amplification
galaxies
prediction
predictions

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Cen, Renyue ; Gott, J. Richard ; Ostriker, Jeremiah P. ; Turner, Edwin Lewis. / Strong gravitational lensing statistics as a test of cosmogonic scenarios. In: Astrophysical Journal. 1994 ; Vol. 423, No. 1. pp. 1-11.
@article{5f4671c9e9d94b4cbf5ff35d06dcd8e1,
title = "Strong gravitational lensing statistics as a test of cosmogonic scenarios",
abstract = "Gravitational lensing statistics can provide a direct and powerful test of cosmic structure formation theories. Since lensing tests, directly, the magnitude of the nonlinear mass density fluctuations on lines of sight to distant objects, no issues of {"}bias{"} (of mass fluctuations with respect to galaxy density fluctuations) exist here, although lensing observations provide their own ambiguities of interpretation. We develop numerical techniques for generating model density distributions with the very large spatial dynamic range required by lensing considerations and for identifying regions of the simulations capable of multiple image lensing in a conservative and computationally efficient way that should be accurate for splittings significantly larger than 3″. Applying these techniques to existing standard Cold dark matter (CDM) (Ω = 1) and Primeval Baryon Isocurvature (PBI) (Ω = 0.2) simulations (normalized to the COBE amplitude), we find that the CDM model predicts large splitting (>8″) lensing events roughly an order-of-magnitude more frequently than the PBI model. Under the reasonable but idealized assumption that lensing structures can be modeled as singular isothermal spheres (SIS), the predictions can be directly compared to observations of lensing events in quasar samples. Several large splitting (Δθ > 8″) cases are predicted in the standard CDM model (the exact number being dependent on the treatment of amplification bias), whereas none is observed. In a formal sense, the comparison excludes the CDM model at high confidence (essentially for the same reason that CDM predicts excessive small-scale cosmic velocity dispersions.) A very rough assessment of low-density but flat CDM model (Ω = 0.3, Λ/3H2 0 = 0.7) indicates a far lower and probably acceptable level of lensing. The PBI model is consistent with, but not strongly tested by, the available lensing data, and other open models would presumably do as well as PBI. These preliminary conclusions and the assumptions on which they are based can be tested and the analysis can be applied to other cosmogonic models by straightforward extension of the work presented here.",
author = "Renyue Cen and Gott, {J. Richard} and Ostriker, {Jeremiah P.} and Turner, {Edwin Lewis}",
year = "1994",
month = "3",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "423",
pages = "1--11",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal",
issn = "0004-637X",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

Strong gravitational lensing statistics as a test of cosmogonic scenarios. / Cen, Renyue; Gott, J. Richard; Ostriker, Jeremiah P.; Turner, Edwin Lewis.

In: Astrophysical Journal, Vol. 423, No. 1, 01.03.1994, p. 1-11.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Strong gravitational lensing statistics as a test of cosmogonic scenarios

AU - Cen, Renyue

AU - Gott, J. Richard

AU - Ostriker, Jeremiah P.

AU - Turner, Edwin Lewis

PY - 1994/3/1

Y1 - 1994/3/1

N2 - Gravitational lensing statistics can provide a direct and powerful test of cosmic structure formation theories. Since lensing tests, directly, the magnitude of the nonlinear mass density fluctuations on lines of sight to distant objects, no issues of "bias" (of mass fluctuations with respect to galaxy density fluctuations) exist here, although lensing observations provide their own ambiguities of interpretation. We develop numerical techniques for generating model density distributions with the very large spatial dynamic range required by lensing considerations and for identifying regions of the simulations capable of multiple image lensing in a conservative and computationally efficient way that should be accurate for splittings significantly larger than 3″. Applying these techniques to existing standard Cold dark matter (CDM) (Ω = 1) and Primeval Baryon Isocurvature (PBI) (Ω = 0.2) simulations (normalized to the COBE amplitude), we find that the CDM model predicts large splitting (>8″) lensing events roughly an order-of-magnitude more frequently than the PBI model. Under the reasonable but idealized assumption that lensing structures can be modeled as singular isothermal spheres (SIS), the predictions can be directly compared to observations of lensing events in quasar samples. Several large splitting (Δθ > 8″) cases are predicted in the standard CDM model (the exact number being dependent on the treatment of amplification bias), whereas none is observed. In a formal sense, the comparison excludes the CDM model at high confidence (essentially for the same reason that CDM predicts excessive small-scale cosmic velocity dispersions.) A very rough assessment of low-density but flat CDM model (Ω = 0.3, Λ/3H2 0 = 0.7) indicates a far lower and probably acceptable level of lensing. The PBI model is consistent with, but not strongly tested by, the available lensing data, and other open models would presumably do as well as PBI. These preliminary conclusions and the assumptions on which they are based can be tested and the analysis can be applied to other cosmogonic models by straightforward extension of the work presented here.

AB - Gravitational lensing statistics can provide a direct and powerful test of cosmic structure formation theories. Since lensing tests, directly, the magnitude of the nonlinear mass density fluctuations on lines of sight to distant objects, no issues of "bias" (of mass fluctuations with respect to galaxy density fluctuations) exist here, although lensing observations provide their own ambiguities of interpretation. We develop numerical techniques for generating model density distributions with the very large spatial dynamic range required by lensing considerations and for identifying regions of the simulations capable of multiple image lensing in a conservative and computationally efficient way that should be accurate for splittings significantly larger than 3″. Applying these techniques to existing standard Cold dark matter (CDM) (Ω = 1) and Primeval Baryon Isocurvature (PBI) (Ω = 0.2) simulations (normalized to the COBE amplitude), we find that the CDM model predicts large splitting (>8″) lensing events roughly an order-of-magnitude more frequently than the PBI model. Under the reasonable but idealized assumption that lensing structures can be modeled as singular isothermal spheres (SIS), the predictions can be directly compared to observations of lensing events in quasar samples. Several large splitting (Δθ > 8″) cases are predicted in the standard CDM model (the exact number being dependent on the treatment of amplification bias), whereas none is observed. In a formal sense, the comparison excludes the CDM model at high confidence (essentially for the same reason that CDM predicts excessive small-scale cosmic velocity dispersions.) A very rough assessment of low-density but flat CDM model (Ω = 0.3, Λ/3H2 0 = 0.7) indicates a far lower and probably acceptable level of lensing. The PBI model is consistent with, but not strongly tested by, the available lensing data, and other open models would presumably do as well as PBI. These preliminary conclusions and the assumptions on which they are based can be tested and the analysis can be applied to other cosmogonic models by straightforward extension of the work presented here.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=12044252336&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=12044252336&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 423

SP - 1

EP - 11

JO - Astrophysical Journal

JF - Astrophysical Journal

SN - 0004-637X

IS - 1

ER -